Commercial Antitrust Field Case

Case 1: Commercial E-Discovery & Spoliation Audit

How Irongate student paralegals and digital forensics scholars audited 2.4 terabytes of unstructured corporate communications to uncover deleted custodian records and establish spoliation under FRCP Rule 37(e).

Download Telemetry (CSV) Litigation Cost Model (XLSX) Legal Tech Certificate
2.4 Terabytes
Unstructured Data Audited
14 Custodians
Corporate C-Suite Targets
FRCP 37(e)
Spoliation Sanctions Issued
$1.42M
Court-Awarded Fee Sanction

Litigation Context & Factual Background

In a complex federal antitrust lawsuit filed in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, plaintiffs alleged an illegal market-allocation scheme between major Tier-1 automotive suppliers in Southeast Michigan. When the defense produced an suspiciously sparse set of executive emails, plaintiffs retained the Irongate Legal Tech & E-Discovery Clinic to conduct an independent electronic discovery forensic audit.

Relativity document review cluster chart for automotive antitrust case

Cluster visualization of 1,200,000 corporate records in Relativity 12 showing missing communication intervals.

Forensic Audit Methodology & Execution

Working under the direction of Dean Brenda Washington-Ellis, six student paralegal fellows ingested 2.4TB of multi-custodian PST archives and forensic raw disk images into the college's dedicated Relativity environment. The investigative sequence followed a rigorous 4-stage protocol:

  1. De-Duplication & Hashing: MD5 and SHA-256 cryptographic hashes were computed across 1,248,000 individual documents to establish chain of custody.
  2. Timeline Gap Analysis: Discrepancies between custodian email server logs and backup tapes revealed that 48,000 emails were systematically purged 14 days after litigation hold notices were issued.
  3. TAR 2.0 Predictive Coding: Students trained machine learning models on a benchmark training corpus of 5,000 documents to identify price-fixing terminology veiled in automotive jargon.
  4. Privilege Log Reconstruction: Defense claims of attorney-client privilege were systematically audited, disproving privilege over 1,420 withheld emails containing purely commercial pricing discussions.
Attorney-client privilege log table with federal court stamps

Standardized attorney-client privilege audit log reviewing 1,420 withheld emails.

Judicial Ruling & Impact

Following a three-day evidentiary hearing in federal court where Irongate student fellows testified regarding their forensic hash validation protocols, Chief District Judge Gerald Rosen granted an adverse inference jury instruction against the defense under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e)(2) and awarded plaintiffs $1,420,000 in attorneys' fees and e-discovery forensic costs.

Exemplary Student Telemetry Dataset

Download the de-identified email metadata corpus containing 1,200 structured telemetry rows, custodian IDs, SHA-256 integrity hashes, privilege status flags, and TAR predictive relevance scores.

Download ediscovery-email-metadata-corpus.csv